verified · verified narrowed
Creators debate whether Adobe's strong fundamentals can outrun AI-disruption fears
The central debate among creators covering Adobe is whether generative AI is an existential threat to its business or an overblown fear. Joseph Carlson argues that while Adobe will post great numbers, it needs to show a stronger defense against AI and is currently viewed as a company with temporary pricing power and a high probability of being disrupted. Monetary Matters frames it as real disruption concerns that haven't yet shown up in the numbers, noting Adobe keeps growing top and bottom line and announcing big share buybacks while also having an AI tool. On the more constructive side, Learn to Invest owns shares and thinks the market has overreacted, viewing the stock as a value and saying they might average down. FAST Graphs describes Adobe as a pure growth stock coming down into fair value. Sven Carlin lays out a wide range of outcomes, suggesting a 3x-5x if it grows at 15%, but warns that if earnings deteriorate, buybacks made at higher prices won't look good.
What changed: Creator sentiment has been improving recently even as the group remains net critical, and several point to the stock trading near value or fair-value levels; Learn to Invest says the market has overreacted and FAST Graphs sees Adobe coming down into fair value.
Where creators align: Multiple creators agree Adobe currently looks reasonably valued or cheap—Cestrian calls it cheap on fundamental multiples, FAST Graphs sees it coming into fair value, Learn to Invest calls it a value, and Monetary Matters says it appears moderately valued at four times sales.
Where creators diverge: Creators split sharply on the AI threat: Brian Stoffel sold out entirely because he sees the long-term thesis as challenged, while Learn to Invest is a big fan who is happy to hold and may average down, and Ticker Symbol: YOU frames AI as being wired into Adobe's workflows rather than simply displacing them.
The short-term view: On the technical/short-term side, EarningsBeats notes the stock was sitting near a 52-week low relative to the market going into earnings, and Trade Brigade flags another failed breakout.
What to watch: Joseph Carlson says the key is whether Adobe can create a stronger defense showing AI is not disrupting the business, and Monetary Matters flags whether disruption eventually shows up in the still-growing numbers.
narrative generated Jul 10, 2026
Supporting receipts
Watch video ↗No timestamp available in this export.co-work really attacks the document cloud because this business is being easily disrupted by anthropic and on the creative cloud side I will admit that co-work is not a huge threat there but there are other AI image machines that are rapidly improving that could do that... these
— Brian Stoffel
Watch video ↗No timestamp available in this export.Adobe will undoubtedly post great numbers, but they need to show some way that AI is not disrupting the business. They need to create a stronger defense for that. Right now, Adobee's looked at as a company that has temporary pricing power and a high probability of being disrupted
— Joseph Carlson
Watch video ↗No timestamp available in this export.I completely sold out of Salesforce and Adobe because of this... Adobe the same thing. The immediate threat is less actually with Adobe, but as these tools get better and better and better and better every week. I think that the long-term thesis for Adobe and Salesforce is challe
— Brian Stoffel
Watch video ↗No timestamp available in this export.ADBE for Adobe. Another one failed breakout over here.
— Trade Brigade
Counterpoints
Watch video ↗No timestamp available in this export.Look at Adobe. Look what's happened to Adobe in recent years. And now this is a pure growth stock. This really coming down into fair value and it's more growthy, doesn't pay any dividends, but it's value. There's gold mines in here.
— FAST Graphs
Watch video ↗No timestamp available in this export.I personally own a bit of Adobe shares... I think that the stock market has overreacted to it. It does look like a value at this point. So, I'm happy to hold my shares. I might even consider averaging down a little bit. Uh but overall, I'm a big fan of Adobe.
— Learn to Invest
